Mielőtt a részletekbe belemennék, szögezzük le: a lista egy érdekesség, egy játék a számokkal, semmi több. Nagyjából annyit ér, mint a boxrec.com listái. Valamilyen támpont ad különböző korok bokszolóinak megítéléséhez, összehasonlításához, de véletlenül sem az egyetemes igazság, komolyabb következtetéseket levonni belőle nem lehet és nem is érdemes.
A listát minden évben úgy generálják, hogy az év végén 9 bokszszakember (újságíró, edző, ökölvívó, szakkommentátor) leadja a saját top10-es listáját és hozzáveszik még az aktuális Ring P4P top10-et, majd ezeket összesítik. A szakírók által rangsorolt listákon az első helyezettek 15-15, a másodikak 12-12, a harmadikak 9, a negyedikek 8, az ötödikek 6, a hatodikak 5, a hetedikek 4, a nyolcadikak 3, a kilencedikek 2 , és a tizedikek 1 pontot kapnak. Ezek a pontok összeadódnak és az összpontszámokból alakul ki az adott évi top10.
Ezt a 32 listát összegeztük a bokszolók neve mögött álló pontszámok alapján és az ebből elkészült összesített listát itt láthatjátok:
1 | Roy Jones Jr. | 1330 |
2 | Floyd Mayweather | 1280,5 |
3 | Pernell Whitaker | 881 |
4 | Manny Pacquiao | 879,5 |
5 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 830 |
6 | Marvin Hagler | 768 |
7 | Oscar De La Hoya | 742 |
8 | Bernard Hopkins | 725 |
9 | Mike Tyson | 627 |
10 | Shane Mosley | 553 |
11 | Evander Holyfield | 537 |
12 | Felix Trinidad | 534 |
13 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 500 |
14 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 398 |
15 | Ricardo Lopez | 369 |
16 | Thomas Hearns | 363 |
17 | Larry Holmes | 352 |
18 | Marco Antonio Barrera | 292 |
19 | Winky Wright | 279 |
20 | Michael Spinks | 263 |
21 | Joe Calzaghe | 239 |
22 | Alexis Arguello | 228 |
23 | Terry Norris | 225 |
24 | Kostya Tszyu | 212 |
25 | Aaron Pryor | 200 |
26 | Donald Curry | 192 |
27 | Hector Camacho | 182 |
28 | Azumah Nelson | 179 |
29 | Wilfredo Gomez | 174 |
30 | Meldrick Taylor | 166 |
31 | Sergio Martinez | 148 |
32 | James Toney | 147 |
33 | Lennox Lewis | 143 |
34 | Jeff Chandler | 129 |
35 | Michael Nunn | 116 |
36 | Nonito Donaire | 116 |
37 | Mark Johnson | 114 |
38 | Andre Ward | 113 |
39 | Wilfred Benitez | 112 |
40 | Naseem Hamed | 110 |
41 | Buddy McGirt | 109 |
42 | Roberto Duran | 109 |
43 | Rafael Marquez | 109 |
44 | Erik Morales | 103 |
45 | Orlando Canizalez | 97 |
46 | Eusebio Pedrosa | 96 |
47 | Jermain Taylor | 95 |
48 | Riddick Bowe | 89 |
49 | Israel Vazquez | 80 |
50 | Ricky Hatton | 79 |
51 | Miguel Cotto | 79 |
52 | Vernon Forrest | 78 |
53 | Salvador Sanchez | 72 |
54 | Jeff Fenech | 71 |
55 | Edwin Rosario | 70 |
56 | Danny Lopez | 65 |
57 | Paul Williams | 60 |
58 | Jose Luis Castillo | 55 |
59 | Pipino Cuevas | 54 |
60 | Frankie Randall | 53 |
61 | Mike McCallum | 53 |
62 | Wladimir Klitschko | 53 |
63 | Humberto Gonzalez | 52 |
64 | Antonio Margarito | 52 |
65 | Buster Douglas | 51 |
66 | Matthew Saad Muhammad | 49 |
67 | Simon Brown | 48 |
68 | Chad Dawson | 48 |
69 | Timothy Bradley | 46 |
70 | Diego Corrales | 44 |
71 | Michael Carbajal | 39 |
72 | Ike Quartey | 37 |
73 | Gerald McClellan | 33 |
74 | Barry McGuigan | 32 |
75 | Zab Judah | 31 |
76 | Antonio Tarver | 30 |
77 | Eddie Mustapha Muhammad | 28 |
78 | Kevin Kelly | 28 |
79 | Antonio Esparragoza | 25 |
80 | Khaosai Galaxy | 25 |
81 | Milton McCrory | 25 |
82 | Vito Antuofermo | 25 |
83 | Jung Koo Chang | 23 |
84 | Junior Jones | 22 |
85 | Pinklon Thomas | 22 |
86 | Juan Manuel Lopez | 21 |
87 | Kelly Pavlik | 21 |
88 | Pongsaklek Wonjongkam | 19 |
89 | Johnny Tapia | 18 |
90 | Julian Jackson | 18 |
91 | Sumbu Kalambay | 18 |
92 | Marlon Starling | 16 |
93 | Fernando Vargas | 15 |
94 | Ivan Calderon | 15 |
95 | Dwight Muhammad Qawi | 14 |
96 | Artur Abraham | 14 |
97 | Juan Diaz | 13 |
98 | Yuri Arbachakov | 11 |
99 | Lucian Bute | 11 |
Néhány megjegyzés:
- Roberto Duran, Wilfredo Gomez, Larry Holmes és Sugar Ray Leonard nyilván előrébb lenne egy képzeletbeli teljes listán, mivel az ő karrierjük részint a hetvenes években volt a csúcson (főleg Duran-ra igaz ez)
- hasonló kategória a Mayweather, Pacquiao, Marquez, Martinez, Ward, Donaire, Bradley, stb. csoport, akik a jövőben növelhetik még pontszámaikat
-87-ben nem készült ilyen lista, így ott a 86-os és a 88-as évek átlagát vettük alapul.
Itt pedig a 32 év 32 P4P listája külön-külön (a listák neten máshol nincsenek fenn - legalábbis én nem találtam):
2011 | ||
1 | Floyd Mayweather | 136.5 |
2 | Manny Pacquiao | 127.5 |
3 | Sergio Martinez | 80 |
4 | Andre Ward | 65 |
5 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 57 |
6 | Nonito Donaire | 53 |
7 | Wladimir Klitschko | 33 |
8 | Timothy Bradley | 19 |
9 | Pongsaklek Wonjongkam | 19 |
10 | Lucian Bute | 11 |
2010 | ||
1 | Manny Pacquiao | 150 |
2 | Floyd Mayweather | 117 |
3 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 76 |
4 | Sergio Martinez | 68 |
5 | Andre Ward | 48 |
6 | Nonito Donaire | 41 |
7 | Timothy Bradley | 27 |
8 | Bernard Hopkins | 24 |
9 | Juan Manuel Lopez | 21 |
10 | Wladimir Klitschko | 20 |
2009 | ||
1 | Manny Pacquiao | 144 |
2 | Floyd Mayweather | 126 |
3 | Shane Mosley | 79 |
4 | Bernard Hopkins | 61 |
5 | Chad Dawson | 48 |
6 | Paul Williams | 42 |
7 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 40 |
8 | Nonito Donaire | 22 |
9 | Ivan Calderon | 15 |
10 | Artur Abraham | 14 |
2008 | ||
1 | Manny Pacquiao | 150 |
2 | Joe Calzaghe | 101 |
3 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 99 |
4 | Bernard Hopkins | 73 |
5 | Antonio Margarito | 52 |
6 | Israel Vazquez | 50 |
7 | Rafael Marquez | 31 |
8 | Miguel Cotto | 28 |
9 | Ricky Hatton | 18 |
9 | Paul Williams | 18 |
2007 | ||
1 | Floyd Mayweather | 150 |
2 | Manny Pacquiao | 103 |
3 | Joe Calzaghe | 89 |
4 | Bernard Hopkins | 63 |
5 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 58 |
6 | Miguel Cotto | 51 |
7 | Israel Vazquez | 30 |
8 | Kelly Pavlik | 21 |
9 | Winky Wright | 15 |
10 | Juan Diaz | 13 |
10 | Oscar De La Hoya | 13 |
2006 | ||
1 | Floyd Mayweather | 141 |
2 | Manny Pacquiao | 129 |
3 | Winky Wright | 81 |
4 | Jermain Taylor | 61 |
5 | Joe Calzaghe | 49 |
6 | Rafael Marquez | 28 |
7 | Ricky Hatton | 23 |
8 | Shane Mosley | 20 |
9 | Jose Luis Castillo | 19 |
10 | Bernard Hopkins | 16 |
2005 | ||
1 | Floyd Mayweather | 144 |
2 | Winky Wright | 113 |
3 | Marco Antonio Barrera | 70 |
4 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 43 |
5 | Rafael Marquez | 39 |
6 | Ricky Hatton | 38 |
7 | Jose Luis Castillo | 36 |
8 | Jermain Taylor | 34 |
9 | Zab Judah | 31 |
10 | Antonio Tarver | 30 |
2004 | ||
1 | Bernard Hopkins | 150 |
2 | Floyd Mayweather | 111 |
3 | Kostya Tszyu | 88 |
4 | Winky Wright | 70 |
5 | Marco Antonio Barrera | 52 |
6 | Manny Pacquiao | 38 |
7 | Erik Morales | 26 |
8 | Juan Manuel Marquez | 25 |
9 | Felix Trinidad | 22 |
10 | Diego Corrales | 11 |
10 | Rafael Marquez | 11 |
2003 | ||
1 | Roy Jones | 142 |
2 | Bernard Hopkins | 114 |
3 | Floyd Mayweather | 97 |
4 | Shane Mosley | 53 |
5 | Kostya Tszyu | 48 |
6 | Oscar De La Hoya | 45 |
7 | Manny Pacquiao | 38 |
8 | James Toney | 35 |
9 | Erik Morales | 31 |
10 | Lennox Lewis | 22 |
2002 | ||
1 | Roy Jones | 135 |
2 | Oscar De La Hoya | 89 |
3 | Marco Antonio Barrera | 78 |
3 | Vernon Forrest | 78 |
3 | Bernard Hopkins | 78 |
6 | Floyd Mayweather | 45 |
7 | Lennox Lewis | 43 |
8 | Kostya Tszyu | 42 |
9 | Erik Morales | 25 |
10 | Shane Mosley | 13 |
2001 | ||
1 | Shane Mosley | 132 |
2 | Roy Jones | 108 |
3 | Bernard Hopkins | 98 |
4 | Floyd Mayweather | 77 |
5 | Marco Antonio Barrera | 44 |
6 | Oscar De La Hoya | 40 |
7 | Felix Trinidad | 39 |
8 | Kostya Tszyu | 34 |
9 | Lennox Lewis | 23 |
10 | Ricardo Lopez | 22 |
2000 | ||
1 | Felix Trinidad | 126 |
2 | Shane Mosley | 123 |
3 | Roy Jones | 109 |
4 | Oscar De La Hoya | 43 |
5 | Floyd Mayweather | 39 |
6 | Naseem Hamed | 37 |
7 | Ricardo Lopez | 35 |
8 | Diego Corrales | 33 |
9 | Bernard Hopkins | 32 |
10 | Lennox Lewis | 31 |
1999 | ||
1 | Roy Jones | 150 |
2 | Oscar De La Hoya | 85 |
3 | Floyd Mayweather | 78 |
4 | Shane Mosley | 68 |
4 | Felix Trinidad | 68 |
6 | Mark Johnson | 47 |
6 | Ricardo Lopez | 47 |
8 | Erik Morales | 21 |
9 | Bernard Hopkins | 16 |
10 | Fernando Vargas | 15 |
1998 | ||
1 | Roy Jones | 141 |
2 | Oscar De La Hoya | 123 |
3 | Felix Trinidad | 67 |
4 | Shane Mosley | 65 |
5 | Evander Holyfield | 55 |
6 | Mark Johnson | 45 |
7 | Naseem Hamed | 33 |
8 | Ricardo Lopez | 23 |
9 | Floyd Mayweather | 19 |
10 | Pernell Whitaker | 14 |
1997 | ||
1 | Oscar De La Hoya | 123 |
2 | Roy Jones | 117 |
3 | Ricardo Lopez | 83 |
4 | Evander Holyfield | 80 |
5 | Felix Trinidad | 65 |
6 | Pernell Whitaker | 37 |
7 | Naseem Hamed | 28 |
8 | Mark Johnson | 22 |
8 | Junior Jones | 22 |
10 | Johnny Tapia | 18 |
1996 | ||
1 | Roy Jones | 123 |
2 | Oscar De La Hoya | 107 |
3 | Pernell Whitaker | 92 |
4 | Evander Holyfield | 64 |
5 | Felix Trinidad | 59 |
6 | Ricardo Lopez | 56 |
7 | Terry Norris | 28 |
8 | Ike Quartey | 21 |
9 | Azumah Nelson | 12 |
10 | Yuri Arbachakov | 11 |
1995 | ||
1 | Roy Jones | 138 |
2 | Pernell Whitaker | 126 |
3 | Oscar De La Hoya | 74 |
4 | Felix Trinidad | 59 |
5 | Marco Antonio Barrera | 48 |
6 | Riddick Bowe | 44 |
7 | Ricardo Lopez | 37 |
8 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 18 |
9 | Ike Quartey | 16 |
10 | Naseem Hamed | 12 |
1994 | ||
1 | Pernell Whitaker | 130 |
2 | Roy Jones | 129 |
3 | Frankie Randall | 53 |
4 | Ricardo Lopez | 45 |
5 | Orlando Canizalez | 39 |
6 | Humberto Gonzalez | 38 |
7 | James Toney | 36 |
8 | Gerald McClellan | 33 |
9 | Felix Trinidad | 29 |
10 | Kevin Kelly | 28 |
1993 | ||
1 | Pernell Whitaker | 147 |
2 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 86 |
3 | Terry Norris | 84 |
4 | James Toney | 76 |
5 | Michael Carbajal | 39 |
6 | Evander Holyfield | 36 |
7 | Buddy McGirt | 28 |
8 | Roy Jones | 23 |
9 | Orlando Canizalez | 22 |
10 | Ricardo Lopez | 21 |
1992 | ||
1 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 136 |
2 | Terry Norris | 91 |
3 | Pernell Whitaker | 85 |
4 | Buddy McGirt | 60 |
5 | Riddick Bowe | 45 |
6 | Orlando Canizalez | 36 |
7 | Azumah Nelson | 34 |
8 | Lennox Lewis | 24 |
9 | Julian Jackson | 18 |
10 | Roy Jones | 15 |
10 | Mike McCallum | 15 |
1991 | ||
1 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 138 |
2 | Pernell Whitaker | 100 |
3 | Evander Holyfield | 78 |
4 | Mike Tyson | 55 |
5 | Meldrick Taylor | 48 |
6 | Mike McCallum | 38 |
7 | Thomas Hearns | 34 |
8 | Khaosai Galaxy | 25 |
9 | Terry Norris | 22 |
10 | Simon Brown | 21 |
1990 | ||
1 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 123 |
2 | Pernell Whitaker | 104 |
3 | Mike Tyson | 71 |
4 | Meldrick Taylor | 57 |
5 | Buster Douglas | 51 |
6 | Simon Brown | 27 |
7 | Antonio Esparragoza | 25 |
8 | Michael Nunn | 23 |
9 | Evander Holyfield | 21 |
10 | Humberto Gonzalez | 14 |
1989 | ||
1 | Mike Tyson | 147 |
2 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 91 |
3 | Meldrick Taylor | 61 |
4 | Michael Nunn | 60 |
5 | Evander Holyfield | 56 |
6 | Pernell Whitaker | 46 |
7 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 28 |
8 | Jeff Fenech | 27 |
9 | Azumah Nelson | 18 |
10 | Marlon Starling | 16 |
1988 | ||
1 | Mike Tyson | 144 |
2 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 118 |
3 | Evander Holyfield | 66 |
4 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 55 |
5 | Jeff Fenech | 44 |
6 | Michael Nunn | 33 |
7 | Azumah Nelson | 32 |
8 | Jung Koo Chang | 23 |
9 | Buddy McGirt | 21 |
10 | Sumbu Kalambay | 18 |
1987 | ||
1 | Mike Tyson | 118 |
2 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 72 |
3 | Marvin Hagler | 69 |
4 | Evander Holyfield | 49 |
5 | Azumah Nelson | 38 |
6 | Donald Curry | 29 |
7 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 27 |
8 | Thomas Hearns | 26 |
9 | Edwin Rosario | 23 |
10 | Michael Spinks | 22 |
1986 | ||
1 | Marvin Hagler | 138 |
2 | Mike Tyson | 92 |
3 | Donald Curry | 59 |
4 | Thomas Hearns | 52 |
5 | Edwin Rosario | 47 |
6 | Azumah Nelson | 45 |
6 | Michael Spinks | 45 |
8 | Evander Holyfield | 32 |
9 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 26 |
10 | Hector Camacho | 22 |
1985 | ||
1 | Marvin Hagler | 150 |
2 | Hector Camacho | 86 |
3 | Michael Spinks | 85 |
4 | Donald Curry | 78 |
5 | Thomas Hearns | 42 |
6 | Barry McGuigan | 32 |
7 | Milton McCrory | 25 |
8 | Julio Cesar Chavez | 22 |
8 | Pinklon Thomas | 22 |
10 | Larry Holmes | 21 |
1984 | ||
1 | Marvin Hagler | 112 |
2 | Aaron Pryor | 77 |
3 | Larry Holmes | 72 |
4 | Eusebio Pedrosa | 66 |
5 | Hector Camacho | 50 |
6 | Jeff Chandler | 47 |
6 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 47 |
8 | Michael Spinks | 45 |
9 | Thomas Hearns | 34 |
10 | Donald Curry | 26 |
1983 | ||
1 | Marvin Hagler | 147 |
2 | Aaron Pryor | 93 |
3 | Larry Holmes | 91 |
4 | Michael Spinks | 66 |
5 | Jeff Chandler | 57 |
6 | Thomas Hearns | 45 |
7 | Alexis Arguello | 29 |
8 | Wilfredo Gomez | 28 |
9 | Hector Camacho | 24 |
10 | Eusebio Pedrosa | 12 |
1982 | ||
1 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 142 |
2 | Alexis Arguello | 97 |
3 | Marvin Hagler | 76 |
4 | Salvador Sanchez | 72 |
5 | Wilfred Benitez | 68 |
6 | Larry Holmes | 61 |
7 | Jeff Chandler | 25 |
8 | Eusebio Pedrosa | 18 |
9 | Aaron Pryor | 17 |
10 | Thomas Hearns | 14 |
10 | Dwight Muhammad Qawi | 14 |
1981 | ||
1 | Thomas Hearns | 116 |
2 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 108 |
3 | Marvin Hagler | 76 |
4 | Larry Holmes | 75 |
5 | Alexis Arguello | 62 |
6 | Wilfredo Gomez | 58 |
7 | Eddie Mustapha Muhammad | 28 |
8 | Matthew Saad Muhammad | 24 |
9 | Wilfred Benitez | 18 |
10 | Roberto Duran | 13 |
10 | Aaron Pryor | 13 |
1980 | ||
1 | Roberto Duran | 96 |
2 | Sugar Ray Leonard | 93 |
3 | Wilfredo Gomez | 88 |
4 | Danny Lopez | 65 |
5 | Pipino Cuevas | 54 |
6 | Alexis Arguello | 40 |
7 | Larry Holmes | 32 |
8 | Wilfred Benitez | 26 |
9 | Vito Antuofermo | 25 |
9 | Matthew Saad Muhammad | 25 |
2012.05.17 edge